|
“The
geopolitics of sexual frustration.” That’s how Martin
Walker, a senior fellow at the New School University of
New York, refers to an underappreciated risk to Asia’s
economic outlook.
French
demographer Christophe Guilmoto calls it “masculinization.”
Others put it more bluntly: “The penis preference.”
No
matter what one calls it, the desire for sons in China,
India and other Asian economies is causing a dangerous
gender gap. In China, for example, 120 boys were born
for every 100 girls in 2005, according to a new United
Nations report. This growing testosterone glut is
something investors making long-term bets on Asia should
be monitoring, and closely.
“Sex-ratio imbalances only lead to far-reaching
imbalances in society,” Thoraya Ahmed Obaid, head of the
UN Population Fund, said in Hyderabad, India, on October
29. “We must carry forward the message that every human
being is born equal in dignity, worth and human rights.”
Tell
that to the ever-growing numbers of families from
Beijing to New Delhi and from Hanoi to Kathmandu
actively avoiding the birth of daughters. It’s a
cultural phenomenon governments have yet to address
sufficiently, and one that could have unexpected
economic side effects.
The
preference for boys often boils down to economics. Sons
tend to support parents in their old age, while
daughters are often seen as a liability. Families
sometimes need to pay a dowry when daughters marry. In
some cultures, sons perform last rites when parents die
and continue the family name.
It’s a
bit of Darwinism in reverse. Families are conducting a
kind of unnatural selection process to get ahead
economically. Yet, hundreds of millions of households
engaging in such an experiment may backfire on entire
economies. Guilmoto, who wrote the UN report, says men
will outnumber women by 23 million in India and by 26
million in China by 2030. Some estimates are even
higher.
In the
1990s, economist Amartya Sen drew attention to the
phenomenon of “missing women.” Improved census data now
allow us to see how much the trend is growing and could
undermine Asian growth, productivity and lead to bigger
budget deficits. It might even lead to an increase in
violence.
This
latter risk was detailed in the 2004 book Bare Branches:
Security Implications of Asia’s Surplus Male Population.
In it, Valerie Hudson and Andrea den Boer warned that
Asia’s shortage of women is giving rise to an entire
generation of young men with no prospects of finding a
mate. They argue that biology, sociology and history
suggest the imbalance will lead to crime and social
disorder.
Far-fetched, perhaps, yet the United Nations warns that
the focus on sons in countries such as China, India,
Nepal and Vietnam may fuel sexual violence and
trafficking in women. The United Nations notes that if
Asia’s overall sex ratio were the same as the rest of
the globe, in 2005 the region would have had 163 million
more females.
Here,
China and India should be the largest concern for
investors. Multinational companies are relying on
increased consumer demand in the two most-populous
nations. So are investors, who are betting on strong
economic growth, rising productivity and an ample supply
of increasingly skilled labor.
“To
address the socioeconomic basis for the preference for
boys, both societies need to reduce the dependence of
parents on their male children, while improving the
economic standing of daughters,” says Jing Ulrich,
chairman of China equities at JPMorgan Chase & Co. in
Hong Kong. “This will require improvements in social
security and policies to improve education and female
participation in the workforce.”
One
consequence of Chinese becoming richer may be more sex
selection, not less. Improving ultrasound and
amniocentesis technology is making it easier for parents
to abort girls, and reports of female infanticide are
becoming routine. The same is true of India; the
wealthier the region, the wider the gender divide is
likely to be.
What
also concerns the United Nations is what all those
single men will do with their desire for female
companionship. Sadly, the real winner could be the
human-trafficking business amid increased demand for
prostitution and the outright purchase of mates.
China’s
government is beginning to address the issue. Earlier
this year, the Communist Party vowed to take “tough
measures” to control the imbalance. Yet China needs to
become more aggressive in tackling a problem that’s
partly at the root of President Hu Jintao’s push for a
“scientific outlook on development.” |