|
Still
buying.
The number of shares owned by San Miguel Corp.
Retirement Plan (SMCRP) in San Miguel Corp. (SMC)
increased to 564,874,101 shares consisting of
411,608,071 A shares and 153,266,030 B shares as of
September 30, 2008 from 562,518,801 shares as of June
30, 2008. The reports show the pension plan bought
additional 2,355,300 SMC shares in the third quarter, or
from July 1-September 30, 2008. Its present ownership
represents 17.896 percent of SMC’s 3,156,373,877
outstanding shares posted on the web site of the
Philippine Stock Exchange and which are divided into
1,920,658,655 A shares and 1,235,715,222 B shares.
SMCRP’s holdings had market value of P34,610,586,191 at
SMC’s 30-day high and P24,707,289,422 at its month’s
low.
Company-financed acquisitions.
SMC has been financing the continued acquisition by
SMCRP of SMC own shares. In a report to regulators, SMC
said its advances to SMCRP as of June 30, 2008 amounted
to P41.224 billion. The amount—which represents 64.411
percent of SMC’s trade and receivables of P64.001
billion—earns 6.5-percent interest per annum, according
to SMC. SMC said its advances to SMCRP—which were
subject to interest of 1 percent above applicable
average three-month treasury rate on the Philippine
Dealing System—amounted to P31.742 billion as of
September 30, 2007, and P35.721 billion as of December
31, 2007, equivalent to 57.727 percent of
P61.879-billion trade and other receivables.
Nondisclosure?
The last
filing made by Manila Electric Co. (Meralco) was posted
on the PSE web site on October 3, 2008. In it, Meralco
told regulators the sale of 2,545 Meralco shares at
P56.50 each by Helen Tamayo de Guzman, vice president
and comptroller on September 30, 2008. The sale reduced
her holdings to 470 Meralco shares. So far, there was no
disclosure on the offer made by (SMC) and Filinvest
Development Corp. (FDC) to buy out the Lopezes from
First Infrastructure Development Corp. (FPIDC), formerly
City Resources Corp. If there was, then Due diligencer
failed to exert enough efforts in finding the disclosure
made by the two losing bidders for the Lopezes’s
98.1246-percent holdings in FPIDC, which eventually went
to Metro Pacific Investments Corp.
Who
should make the filing?
The
disclosure that SMC and FDC made their offer to acquire
FPIDC from the Lopezes did not come from the PSE web
site but from a press release dated October 3, 2008 and
which was issued by Pete Ilagan, president of the
National Association of Electricity Consumers for
Reforms. If there was a serious offer made in writing,
then it should have been properly disclosed to the
Philippine Stock Exchange (PSE) and the Securities and
Exchange Commission (SEC). Had the parties failed in
complying with the rules on transparency, then the
regulators should go after who should be answerable for
the nondisclosure of material fact which could have
affected the prices of FPIDC and of SMC and FDC, which
are also both listed on the exchange. It is now up PSE
and SEC to determine who should have made the proper
filing.
Buying
on credit.
In his statement, Ilagan wrote: “The Lopezes hurriedly
sold to Metro Pacific their stake in FPIDC despite
better offers from SMC and Filinvest Development,
leading observers to conclude that Metro Pac had pledged
to immediately pay FPH.” The initials stand for First
Philippine Holdings (FPH). As the issue is sensitive
enough to affect the market, lawyer Francis Ed Lim, PSE
president and chief executive officer, and SEC chairman
Fe Barin may want to look for who has been remiss in
informing them of the tenders made by SMC and FDC, which
could have been joint-venture partners in operating the
North Luzon Expressway. The officials of the two
“unsuccessful bidders” may also want to disclose how
Ilagan learned that they wanted to buyout the Lopezes on
credit and where they would eventually get the money. In
the case of SMC, it has been using its pension plan in
buying SMC shares in the open market using SMC’s own
corporate funds. |