FORMER senator and Fair Trade Alliance (FTA) lead convenor Wigberto Tañada labeled the exchange of notes between Manila and Tokyo for the Japan-Philippine Economic Partnership Agreement (Jpepa) as “useless” as it failed to address the numerous constitutional issues that were raised by several sectors against the deal.

Tañada particularly cited Paragraph 4 of the exchange of notes as a problematic clause as it stated that it serves only to confirm the interpretation and does not modify the commitments and obligations of both parties under the Jpepa.

“If the exchange of notes does not modify the Jpepa, then it does not serve any useful function. Worse, it even reaffirms the existing provisions, including those that are inconsistent with our Constitution,” Tañada told the BusinessMirror.

He said this only shows the stubbornness of Japan to heed the nationalistic calls of Filipinos and should push the Senate to reject the deal.

Tañada said the senators should not be swayed by the argument of pro-Jpepa camps that the Philippines will miss the boat if the deal is not ratified, considering other countries in the region have already signed their respective bilateral economic partnership agreements (EPAs) with Japan.

He pointed out that it is a different case for the Philippines considering Thailand and the other Asean countries managed to resolve the important constitutional aspects of their EPAs.

“Why can’t we duplicate what the other countries have succeeded in doing?” he said.

The exchange notes were supposed to convince the Senate that the Jpepa will not indeed go against the provisions of the Constitution, particularly those on the national treatment of Japanese investments and the country’s territorial waters that will be opened to Japanese factory ships under the agreement.

Tañada said with that Paragraph 4, the defects of the Jpepa that have been pointed out by FTA and other civic groups will continue to be part of the deal.

Also, Tañada said the Senate should present the exchange of notes to a public hearing before the senators put the ratification to a vote.

“From the start, there has been a problem with the transparency on the part of the government. The Senate should conduct public hearings again so the public will understand what is really going on,” he said.

Tañada said the senators should not be in a hurry in ratifying the deal especially with these serious defects.

If the Senate would immediately concur with the deal, Tañada said the FTA will be forced to go to the Supreme Court to challenge the Jpepa.

Rene Ofreneo, FTA convenor, said the exchange of notes is weak and have several gray areas, making it difficult for the Philippines to legally defend its constitutional mandates.

Ofreneo said the “shared understanding” between the governments of the Philippines and Japan that their respective Charters will not be violated is not firm as it appears to be a mere opinion.

IBON: Donors gave insufficient and poor-quality ODA

DONOR governments and organizations are $30 billion worth short of their programmed official development assistance (ODA) commitments for 2010 and failed to improve the quality of aid worldwide, according to local think tank IBON Foundation Inc.

FDC urges solons to start implementing budget reforms

AS THE House of Representatives started deliberations on the P1.415-trillion 2009 budget, an antidebt watchdog appealed to legislators to start implementing budget reforms by dismantling all the impediments to democracy in the budget process, if they really want to effectively respond to the needs of the people.

Social safety net programs should target self-sustenance, says FAO

SOCIAL safety net programs such as the Philippine government’s cash- transfer program should ensure that the poor will not become dependent on dole-outs, the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) said.

Exchange of notes between RP, Japan for Jpepa ‘useless,’ says Tañada

FORMER senator and Fair Trade Alliance (FTA) lead convenor Wigberto Tañada labeled the exchange of notes between Manila and Tokyo for the Japan-Philippine Economic Partnership Agreement (Jpepa) as “useless” as it failed to address the numerous constitutional issues that were raised by several sectors against the deal.

ERC to determine actual WESM price recoverable from consumers

THE Department of Energy said on Friday the Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC) will determine the actual price recoverable from consumers due to the congestion problem in the San Jose, Bulacan, substation of the National Transmission Corp. (Transco).

DAR links up with Natcco to ensure agrarian-reform credit

THE Department of Agrarian Reform (DAR) has forged ties with the National Confederation of Cooperatives (Natcco) to provide agrarian-reform beneficiaries easy access to credit, considered the key to the successful implementation of the Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program.

Cavite-based integrated ethanol plant set for commercial operation in 2010

LOOKING at joining the ethanol bandwagon, the Cavite Biofuels Producers Inc. (CBPI) said it partnered with the Cavite Sugarcane Planters Multipurpose Cooperative (CSPMPC) in developing a 125,000-liter-per-day bioethanol distillery in the municipality of Magallanes, Cavite. 

Mindanao’s only coal-fired power plant reports zero emission violation

VILLANUEVA, Misamis Oriental—Mindanao’s first and only coal-fired power plant reported zero emission violation since it started operation in November 2006.