|
THE
Supreme Court (SC) will hear on Tuesday the arguments of
the parties in the consolidated petitions questioning
the election of Lakas Rep. Jocelyn Limkaichong of Negros
Oriental on the ground that she is not a natural-born
Filipino citizen.
Lawyers
of Limkaichong are expected to assert his Filipino
citizenship during the oral arguments scheduled at 1:30
p.m. at the new session hall of the SC.
The oral
argument was originally scheduled on Friday but the
Court en banc instead moved it to August 26 through a
resolution a few weeks ago.
In an
advisory issued to the parties, the Court said the
issues to be taken up will be whether the proclamation
of Limkaichong by the provincial board of canvassers of
Negros Oriental is valid and whether the said
proclamation divested the Commission on Elections (Comelec)
of jurisdiction to resolve the issue of Limkaichong’s
citizenship.
Likewise, the parties are tasked to discuss the issue on
whether the House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal
(HRET) should assume jurisdiction, in lieu of the
Comelec, and whether the poll body correctly ruled that
Limkaichong is disqualified from running for
congressman.
The SC
also asked the parties to take up the issue of whether
the Comelec’s initial disqualification of Limkaichong is
final and executory, and whether the speaker of the
House of Representatives may be compelled to prohibit
Limkaichong from assuming her duties as a member of the
Lower House.
Lawyer
Pacifico Agabin, former dean of the University of the
Philippines College of Law, will act as Limkaichong’s
lead counsel.
The
Commission on Elections’ Second Division, in a
resolution issued on May 17, 2007, held that Limkaichong
should be disqualified from seeking a congressional seat
on the ground that she is not a natural-born Filipino
citizen.
Limkaichong’s father, according to her detractors,
failed to acquire Filipino citizenship through
naturalization proceedings before a court.
However,
she insisted that the said Comelec resolution was issued
with grave abuse of discretion. She argued that the
petitions for disqualification against her are “deemed
dismissed” in line with the Comelec en banc’s resolution
issued on August 16, 2007, where all the six
commissioners unanimously ruled that it no longer has
jurisdiction over the petitions for disqualification
against Limkaichong since she was already proclaimed on
May 25, 2007, and that all issues pertaining to her
proclamation is now vested with the HRET.
Under
the Constitution, election cases which are no longer
“pre-proclamation” suits must be handled by the HRET in
recognition of the legislature’s innate right to
determine the fitness of its members.
Article
VI, Section 17 of the 1987 Constitution provides that
the Senate and the House of Representatives shall each
have an electoral tribunal which shall be the sole judge
of all contests relating to the election, returns and
disqualifications of their respective members.
Limkaichong maintained that she is a natural-born
Filipino citizen since at the time of her birth on
November 9, 1959, her father Julio Sy was already a
naturalized Filipino citizen. |