|
THE
Department of Justice (DOJ) has affirmed the authority
of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR)
to supervise the operations and limit the volume of
minerals to be extracted by small-scale mining firms.
In a
letter dated July 30, 2007 and addressed to the then
DENR and now Energy Secretary Angelo Reyes, Justice
Secretary Raul Gonzalez said the DENR under Republic Act
7076, or People’s Small Scale Mining Act of 1991, has
direct supervision and control over the program and
activities of small-scale miners.
Reyes
earlier sought clarification of DOJ Opinion No. 74,
series of 2006, which was allegedly erroneously applied
by Executive Secretary Eduardo Ermita in February this
year to reverse DENR findings of alleged nickel ore
overextraction and other environmental violations
against Platinum Group Metals Corp. (PGMC), a
small-scale mining company in southern Palawan.
Citing
as basis the questioned DOJ opinion, Ermita said R.A.
7076 has lifted the limits imposed on the extraction of
minerals by small-scale miners across the country.
As such,
he reinstated PGMC’s environmental compliance
certificates (ECCs) and operating permits and even
barred DENR agents from enforcing Reyes’s orders to shut
down PGMC’s operations.
Ermita,
however, abandoned his decision following protests by
environmental groups and big mining firms. Instead,
Ermita referred PGMC’s case back to the DENR to
determine whether it should be permanently stripped of
its ECC for nickel ore overextraction.
In his
letter to the DOJ, the former Environment secretary
sought clarification of the proper interpretation of the
DOJ opinion earlier issued by Gonzalez upon the request
of Agusan del Norte Gov. Eripe John Amante seeking
guidance over small-scale mining activities in his
province.
Reyes
specifically asked Gonzalez on whether or not RA 7076
impliedly repealed Section 1 of Presidential Decree 1899
pertaining to the annual production quota limitation of
the small-scale mining permits (SSMP).
Reyes
also sought for the proper interpretation of the word
“nickel-cobalt ore” as indicated in the SSMP and
environmental compliance certificate (ECC).
While
Gonzalez did not categorically state whether RA 7076 has
repealed P.D. 1899 as the law governing small-scale
mining activities, he said various sections of RA 7076
vests upon DENR the power to regulate the small-scale
mining industry.
Among
such powers, the DOJ chief said, include the authority
to set the size and shape of the contract area which in
no case should exceed 20 hectares; assess and regulate
environmental impact and other considerations;
rescission of contracts and imposition of fines; award
of contracts; and formulation and implementation of
rules and regulations pertaining to small-scale mining.
“It is
worthy to emphasize that although RA 7076 is silent with
regard to the 50,000-metric-ton limit, however, said law
gave DENR secretary the authority to set the proper
annual production limit of a small-scale miner.
This can
be derived through the powers given to him under RA
7076,” Gonzalez said in his letter.
Gonzalez
noted that under Section 26 of RA 7076, the secretary
through his representative “shall exercise direct
supervision and control over the program and activities
of the small-scale miners within the people’s
small-scale mining area.”
“It is
clear that the DENR secretary should issue the necessary
implementing rules and regulation in order to address
the gray areas in the implementation of the small-scale
mining law,” the letter added.
In the
same letter, Gonzalez clarified that the word “ore”
pertains to the mined ore in its raw, unprocessed form.
The
proper definition was also one of the clarifications
sought by Reyes following PGMC’s defense that Condition
No. 8 of its ECC contains a provision limiting to 50,000
metric tons the extraction of the metal nickel and not
nickel ore.
“We
agree with your [Reyes’s] view that the word ‘ore’
refers to the raw material that can be mined or
extracted from the earth without undergoing any process
or intervention other than the physical act of removing
the mineral ore from the earth,” the Justice secretary
said. |