|
The Left, online and outraged
By David Finkel
The Washington Post
SHERMAN OAKS, California—In the angry life
of Maryscott O’Connor, the rage begins as soon as she opens
her eyes and realizes that her President is still George W. Bush.
The sun has yet to rise and her family is asleep, but no matter;
as soon as the realization kicks in, O’Connor, 37, is out
of bed and heading toward her computer.
Out there, awaiting her
building fury: the Angry Left, where O’Connor’s reputation
is as one of the angriest of all. “One long, sustained scream”
is how she describes the writing she does for various Web logs,
as she wonders what she should scream about this day.
She smokes a cigarette.
Should it be about Bush, whom she considers “malevolent,”
a “sociopath” and “the Antichrist”? She
smokes another cigarette. Should it be about Vice President Cheney,
whom she thinks of as “Satan,” or about Karl Rove, “the
devil”? Should it be about the “evil” Republican
Party, or the “weaselly, capitulating, self-aggrandizing,
self-serving” Democrats, or the Catholic Church, for which
she says “I have a special place in my heart. . .a burning,
sizzling, putrescent place where the guilty suffer the tortures
of the damned”?
Darfur, she finally decides.
She will write about Darfur. The shame of it. The culpability of
all Americans, including herself, for doing nothing. She will write
something so filled with outrage that it will accomplish the one
thing above all she wants from her anger: to have an effect.
“Darfur is not hopeless,”
she begins typing, and pauses.
“Ugh,” she
says.
“You are not helpless,”
she continues typing, and pauses again.
“Weak.”
She deletes everything
and starts over.
“WAKE THE [expletive]
UP,” she writes next, and this time, instead of pausing, she
keeps going, typing harder and harder on a keyboard that is surrounded
by a pack of cigarettes, a dirty ashtray, a can of nonalcoholic
beer, an album with photos of her dead father and a taped-up note—staring
at her—on which she has scrawled “Why am I/you here?”
These are mean times.
“I just want to see these [expletive] swinging from their
heels in the public square,” reads a recent comment from someone
named Dave in a discussion about the Bush administration on a web
site called Eschaton.
Loud, crass and instantaneous.
“I feel like I’m
being molested everytime I hear his voice,” one person writes
on the Daily Kos web site while watching a Bush news conference.
What’s notable about
this isn’t only the level of anger but the direction from
which it is coming. Not that long ago, it was the Right that was
angry and the Left that was, at least comparatively, polite. But
after years of being the targets of inflammatory rhetoric, not only
from fringe groups but also from such mainstream conservative politicians
as Newt Gingrich, the Left has gone on the attack. And with Republicans
in control of Washington, they have much more to be angry about.
“Powerlessness”
is O’Connor’s explanation. “This is born of powerlessness.”
To what, effect, though?
Do the hundreds of thousands of daily visitors to Daily Kos, who
sign their comments with phrases such as “Anger is energy,”
accomplish anything other than talking among themselves? The founder
of Daily Kos, Markos Moulitsas, may have a wide enough reputation
at this point to consult regularly with Democrats on Capitol Hill,
but what about the heart and soul of Daily Kos, the other visitors,
whose presence extends no further than what they read and write
on the site?
How about the 125,000
or so daily visitors to Eschaton? Or the thousands who visit Rude
Pundit, the Smirking Chimp or My Left Wing, which is O’Connor’s
web site?
Put another way, can one
person sitting alone in a living room, typing her fingertips numb
on a keyboard, make a difference?
“Rage, rage against
the Lying of the Right” is the subtitle of O’Connor’s
web site.
“If I can’t
rant, I don’t want to be part of your revolution” is
how she signs her comments, in the place other people might write
“Sincerely.”
“I was not like
this before,” she says. “I was riddled with empathy
for everyone suffering in the world. Classic bleeding-heart liberal.”
Before: She signed petitions.
She boycotted veal. She canvassed for Greenpeace. She donated to
Planned Parenthood. She read the Nation, the New Yorker, the Utne
Reader and Mother Jones. She agonized over low wages for overseas
workers every time she bought a $40 leather purse.
Then George W. Bush was
elected. Then came 9/11, Afghanistan, Iraq, Guantánamo Bay,
Abu Ghraib, the Patriot Act, secret prisons, domestic eavesdropping,
the revamping of the Supreme Court, and the thought “It has
come to the point where the worst people on Earth are running the
Earth.” And now, “I have become one of those people
with all the bumper stickers on their car,” she says. “I
am this close to being one of those muttering people pushing a cart.
“I’m insane
with rage and grief.
“But I also feel
more connected than I ever have.”
As the responses near 100, O’Connor has a
cigarette.
Now, as they head toward
200, she picks up the album about her father, where there’s
a letter from him to his wife, written three days before he died,
that ends, “I love you and the baby more than I ever knew
a person could love.”
The baby.
He never knew her name,
or that she was a girl, or that his wife weighed less on the day
their daughter was born than when she was conceived. “Catatonic”
is how O’Connor describes what her mother became for a while,
and then the mother got better, and then the daughter got worse,
and then the daughter got better by becoming angry rather than silent
about a new war, so angry she began wishing her President would
go to hell.
“I’ve got
to stop looking at this,” she says, putting the album away
and turning back to the screen.
Meanwhile, over on Eschaton,
Dave is writing, “As a matter of fact—I do hate Bush!”
On Rude Pundit: “George
W. Bush is the anti-Midas. Everything he touches turns to [expletive].”
On the Smirking Chimp:
“I. Despise. These. [Expletive]!”
And on Daily Kos and My
Left Wing, the responses keep rolling in.
“Thank you, Maryscott.”
“Thank you for the
kick in the [expletive].”
“I wrote to my [expletive]
so-called representatives.”
“I also wrote to
my [expletive] congressman to get off his [expletive] [expletive]
and do the right [expletive] thing.”
“You know what?”
O’Connor says. “I did a good thing today.” And
for a moment, anyway, she isn’t angry at all.
|