|
GMA
Network Inc. is a rare listed company. It declares
dividends not out of surplus in prior years but out of
retained earnings plus net profit in current year, which
refers to the year when dividends are declared.
Here is
what happened inside the boardroom of GMA Network before
the company sold shares through an initial public
offering: its board approved the declaration of dividend
amounting to P2.875 billion, of which P375 million was
in stock, in 2007. These dividends came in three
tranches—P1.50 billion on March 19, 2007; P375 million
in stock on April 26, 2007; and P1 billion on July 2,
2007. To determine who were entitled to these dividends,
the board set the record dates on the same dates it
approved them. Because its generosity came before the
sale of GMA Network shares to the public, the Gozons,
Jimenezes and Duavits and their allies benefited from
the board’s generosity, which of course they—the
existing stockholders—proposed and approved through the
board which they control then and now. Incidentally, GMA
Network listed its shares on July 30, 2007 after selling
shares to the public at P8.50 each. The public missed
the board’s charitable gesture by 22 days.
If one
were to review the distribution of dividends by GMA
Network against retained earnings, he or she would find
out that the broadcast group, which owns and operates
Channel 7 and radio station DZBB, did not have enough
surplus in prior year, that is, in 2006, as this
amounted to only P1.94 billion when it was to give out a
total of P2.875-billion dividends, which its board
declared up to July 2, 2007. It was short by P934.84
million!
GMA
Network showed how it could beat the ordinary way of
declaring dividend, which was against surplus of prior
year: it waited for fiscal year 2007 to end. With its
profit for the year, it had more than enough to cover
the year’s P2.875 billion in dividend. The filings
showed the details: As of January 1, 2007, GMA Network
had retained earnings of P1.94 billion, which when added
to its net income of P2.307 billion for the 2007 equals
P4.247 billion, as the report did. By deducting from the
sum the dividends for the year, then GMA Network would
end, and it did, with surplus of P1.372 billion.
(In its
report for the first six months, which was not audited,
GMA Network already deducted P1.5-billion dividend and
P375-million stock dividend from its retained earnings
of P1.94 billion, an amount which was beefed up by
P1.126-billion net profit for the period, leaving the
company with P1.192 billion in retained earnings by the
end of the semester. It omitted P1-billion dividend,
which the board declared on July 2, 2007, which was
outside the six-month period.)
What
happened to the public stockholders who had hoped GMA
Network would end 2007 with a bigger surplus retained
earnings of P4.247 billion (P1.94-billion retained
earnings in 2006 plus 2007 net income of P2.307
billion)? They should wait for GMA Network to pile up
net profits in a few more years before they could expect
dividends, which the company said it would distribute to
its stockholders. But since it is now a public company,
it could no longer be as generous as it was prior to its
IPO; its new policy is to declare dividends only out of
surplus in prior year. This means for 2008, GMA
Network’s P1.372 billion in surplus would translate to
P0.408 per share cash dividend.
****
The
dividends may come later if not sooner for the public
investors who may have to look at the consistent
profitability of GMA Network if only to assuage their
feelings against the use of 2007 net income for the
dividends declared during the year that came too late to
benefit them.
Under
the new dividend policy adopted by GMA Network, how will
its stockholders “receive annual cash dividends
equivalent to a minimum of 50 percent of the prior
year’s net income based on the recommendation of the
board of directors” when it used up its net profit in
2007 as retained earnings to fill up the shortfall in
its surplus for 2006 to pay for its P2.875 billion
dividend its board approved in the first seven months of
2007? If one were to go by the disclosures, GMA Network
would declare this year P1.1535- billion dividend,
whether in cash or in stock. The amount represents 50
percent of net income in 2007.
Again,
here is how generous GMA Network to its owners before
its IPO: The filings posted on the web site of the
Philippine Stock Exchange showed the network reported
total net profits of P7.776 billion in the last four
years—P2.307 billion in 2007; P1.962 billion in 2006;
P2.005 billion in 2005; and P1.50 billion in 2004. In
the same period, it gave out P7.523-billion
dividend—P286-million cash in 2004; P218.521 million in
cash and property and P3 billion in cash in 2005; P1.15
billion in cash and property in 2006; and P2.50 billion
in cash and P375 million in stock in 2007. After these
dividends, P253 million was left of its net profits,
which it registered from 2004 to 2007.
www.duediligencer.com |