|
Amid
problems hounding the agriculture sector due to soaring
rice prices, the National Irrigation Authority (NIA)
continues to post cost increases for two more ongoing
foreign-assisted projects, according to documents from
the National Economic and Development Authority (Neda).
To date,
four out of the six ongoing official development
assistance (ODA)-funded irrigation projects of the NIA
have proposed cost increases worth a total of P4.28
billion. These four projects are the irrigation
component of the Casecnan Multipurpose Irrigation and
Power Projects, stage II of the Bohol Irrigation
Project, Banaoang Pump Irrigation Project and the first
phase of the Help forCatubig Agricultural Advancement
Project.
While
the Casenan and Bohol projects have already been
approved and “noted” by the Neda Investment Coordination
Committee (ICC) Cabinet Committee (Cabcom), the Banaoang
and Catubig projects still need to go through the ICC
Cabcom.
Neda
documents showed that the cost increases of these
projects even go as high as almost 100 percent of its
original project cost, which is the case of the Banaoang
Pump Irrigation project.
The Neda
ICC has yet to approve the NIA’s proposal to increase
the Banaoang project cost by 92.53 percent, or P1.24
billion from the original cost of P1.34 billion.
The
approval has not yet been given by the ICC due to a
pending legal issue on NIA’s approval of the additional
contract cost without seeking ICC approval. The ICC will
soon be meeting to discuss the advice being sought from
the Department of Budget and Management (DBM) on the
issue.
However,
if the questions surrounding the project are resolved
and the proposal of the NIA is granted, the Banaoang
project will amount to P2.58 billion.
The
Banaoang project will be funded by an eight-year, $35
million worth of loan from the Chinese government with a
3- percent annual interest rate. The loan with a grace
period of two years, is set to expire on June 27, 2008
Meanwhile, the project with a cost increase of less than
20 percent, the lowest among the four projects, is the
Catubig project which is also set to be discussed in the
next ICC Cabcom meeting.
The NIA
proposed to increase its project cost by 19.75 percent,
or P490 million. The original cost approved by the ICC
was P2.48 billion, but if the cost increase is granted
the project will now be worth P2.97 billion.
The ICC
Technical Board (TB) endorsed the project for approval
by the ICC Cabcom on April 4 but subject to certain
conditions.
The ICC
TB mandated NIA to submit a detailed information on the
timeline of the completion of specific project
activities within its proposed extension period. The TB
also asked that the additional funding for the project
be covered by the NIA budget.
The TB
also said the NIA should secure a certificate from the
DBM for its proposed funding strategy to finance the
cost increase and the NIA’s inclusion of the proposed
changes in the updating of the Medium-Term Philippine
Investment Plan.
The
project is also funded by a P221 million worth of loan
from the Japan Bank for International Cooperation (JBIC).
The loan has a maturity period of 30 years and a grace
period of 10 years.
The loan
with an interest rate of 2.2 percent per annum, is set
to close on January 23, 2011. Neda documents did not,
however, disclose when the NIA’s revised closing date
for the loan will be.
Meanwhile, the Casecnan project, which is also a JBIC-funded
project, has already been approved by the Neda ICC
Cabcom.
The
project incurred cost overruns due to currency
exchange-rate movements, modification in the scope of
work and increase in right-of-way (ROW) acquisition
cost.
With
that, the Neda ICC-Cabcom granted the project increase
to P7.455 billion from the originally approved P5.832
billion. The P1.623 billion cost increase is 27.83
percent of the project cost.
Further,
the project implementation schedule, which was supposed
to be only until 2005 was extended to 2008. The loan
extension, which was earlier granted by the Neda ICC,
was until January 2009 from January 2007.
On the
other hand, the ICC Cabcom placed a “notation” for the
cost increase requested by the NIA for the Bohol project
on August 30, 2007, which the Neda Board approved on
October 9, 2007.
The NIA
requested for a 51.23-percent cost increase for the
project, or P1.22 billion worth of additional funding.
This has increased its total project cost to P3.61
billion from the originally approved P2.38 billion.
While
the Neda believes that the project cost increase was too
high for the national government to bear, the Department
of Justice (DOJ) in a legal opinion deemed the contract
for the
Bohol project
valid and legal.
The DOJ
cited that the project is not covered by the
Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRRA) Part A of
Republic Act (RA) 9184, or the Government Procurement
Reform Act, since the invitation for the bidding for the
project was made prior to the effectivity of IRR-A of RA
9184
The DOJ
said the IRR-A covers all fully domestically funded
procurement activities from procurement planning up to
contract implementation and termination. The IRR-B for
foreign-funded procurement activities shall be subject
of a subsequent issuance.
Based on
Section 77 of RA 9184, if the advertisement or
invitation for bids were issued prior to the effectivity
of the Act, the provisions set in Executive Order 40 and
its IRR, Presidential Decree 1594 and RA 7160 will be
followed. |