|
THE
Screen Actors Guild Awards, which happens on Sunday at
the Kodak Theater in Los Angeles, California, have
always closely resembled the Oscars, but this Sunday
night’s gala might truly be an early sneak peek at what
the Academy Awards will be.
Never
before has there been such amazing overlap between the
two awards’ lists of contenders. Out of the Oscars’ 20
nominees for acting, 19 are repeated at SAG. Three
categories line up exactly. The other—Best Supporting
Actor—disagrees on only one entry: the Oscars nominated
Mark Wahlberg (The Departed) while SAG opted to
list Leonardo DiCaprio (The Departed)

MEGAN MULLALLY in
Will &
Grace, nominated for Outstanding Performance by a Female
Actor in a Comedy Series.
There’s
an impressive overlap of winners, too, historically
speaking. Over the past 12 years of the SAG Awards’
existence, they agreed 8 times with the Oscars on Best
Actor and 10 times on lead actress. Overlap in the
supporting races is less impressive: 50 percent on the
male side; 7 out of 12 in the race for supporting
actresses.
Over
all, there’s a greater degree of agreement among
nominees because of the way Oscar participants are
determined. Fifteen hundred actors who belong to the
Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences pick Oscar’s
acting contenders, whereas SAG nominees are determined
by 2,100 members chosen randomly among of the guild’s
110,000 national membership.
All SAG
members vote on the winners. Ditto for all 5,800 academy
members, but that’s where the two awards differ. Art
directors and hair stylists end up judging the final
Oscar lineup. Since only actors vote for SAG, the result
is more “pure”—and therefore perhaps even more legit and
worthy if the goal of both awards is to get film work
evaluated by one’s peers.
Forest
Whitaker (Last King of Scotland) and Helen Mirren
(The Queen) are the heavy faves to win Best Actor
and Actress, considering that they won every other top
showbiz award so far. Four out of six experts who make
predictions at The Envelope’s Buzzmeter pick Whitaker
for lead actor (Edward Douglas, Comingsoon.net; Pete
Hammond, HollywoodWiretap.com/Maxim; Gene Seymour,
Newsday, and Clay Smith, “The Insider”). One picks
Leonardo DiCaprio for Blood Diamond (Claudia Puig,
USA Today) and one (me) opts for Peter O’Toole (Venus).
All agree upon Helen Mirren in the actress’ race.
Here’s
how our experts project the race for supporting actor:
Eddie Murphy in Dreamgirls (Douglas, Seymour,
Smith), Alan Arkin in Little Miss Sunshine
(Hammond, Puig), Leo DiCaprio in The Departed
(O’Neil).
Supporting actress: all agree on Jennifer Hudson in
Dreamgirls.
Ensemble: Little Miss Sunshine (Douglas, Hammond,
O’Neil), The Departed (Puig),
Babel (Seymour, Smith).

KATE
WINSLET in
Little Children,
nominated for Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor
in a Leading Role.
Predictions are difficult this year because of the
wild-card effect of DVD screeners. Having 110,000
members, SAG is usually considered to be too expensive
to blitz, but last year Crash won the ensemble
award after becoming the first film to do so. Since the
ensemble award is widely considered to be a precursor of
Best Picture at the Oscars, the Crash victory
helped to fuel the film’s awards buzz right after it was
shut out of the Golden Globes.
This
year three films followed suit by sending DVDs to all
SAG members: The Departed, Venus and
Little Miss Sunshine. If all three pull off big
victories, the timing will be excellent since academy
members will receive final ballots this upcoming week.
Upsets
could help the Academy Award’s biggest loser (Venus
star Peter O’Toole has been snubbed seven times) to
derail the Whitaker juggernaut and get Oscar
satisfaction at last. And a victory in the ensemble race
may help Little Miss Sunshine to topple The
Departed,
Babel or Letters from Iwo Jima in the Oscar best picture
race.
However,
Peter O’Toole won’t be present at the Shrine Auditorium
Sunday night. If he wins, will that matter? O’Toole
hasn’t appeared in Hollywood yet this awards season.
Meryl
Streep (The Devil Wears Prada) won’t attend
either. She’s busy teaming up with Al Gore to cohost the
10th annual benefit for
Harvard Medical School’s
Center for Health and the Global Environment.
Considering that Mirren is such a heavy favorite in the
lead actress’ race, Streep may not feel she’s missing
much, but some kudos-watchers disagree. Some experts
believe that the SAG Awards show a subtle bias toward
Americans. If so, Streep may benefit from being the only
Yankee in the best actress race.
Among
the SAG TV awards, it’s possible that the upcoming
winners may look a lot like that last Emmy or SAG
champs. Very few stars from new TV shows got nominated.
The only rookies:
America
Ferrera (Ugly Betty), Michael C. Hall (Dexter),
and Alec Baldwin (30 Rock) in the solo acting
races and Ugly Betty in the ensemble category.
There’s
some controversy over Boston Legal. Last year it
competed as a comedy series. This year it switched to
the drama side.
Grey’s
Anatomy
is also competing as a drama even though it has lots of
comedic touches. No one is laughing over the travails of
star Isaiah
Washington,
however, as he struggles to cope with the outcry
surrounding his antigay slur. If Grey’s wins as
expected, fans wonder if
Washington will be allowed to join his cast mates on stage.
The
Screen Actor’s Guild Awards air this Sunday at 8 p.m. ET
on TBS and TNT. |